challenge 154: kind of close and crowded

[tinny]

The crop in the first one isn't all that close, because I otherwise couldn't fit them both into the frame. If you think it doesn't fit the theme, feel free to leave it out of the voting.



Zhu Yilong & Yang Enyou (Lighting up the Stars Promo material) 2x | Zhu Yilong & Chen Minghao (LTR BTS) | Crash Landing on You | Yang Yang and Jia Ling (Youth Travel)


https://tinpix.de/2022/zyl_yey_ff_6030783_19wk5o.png
https://tinpix.de/2022/zyl_yey_sina1_00.43a8wki5.png
https://tinpix.de/2022/zyl_cmh_ltr_stx_01.54ibk6g.png
https://tinpix.de/2022/cloy116_01.37.2717jog.png
https://tinpix.de/2022/youthtravel309_01m7k2t.gif

Comments

[luminousdaze]

Yeah, I don't like to examine icons to disqualify them for being off-prompt, either. I'll likely do it only for cheating and content. Maybe I will if the colors are really off for a palette theme, like a green icon instead of a purple icon. I think rules for fitting the prompts really matter if it's land community because it's a game, where challenges earn team points, but not so much for an icontest.

[tinny]

Yes, that makes sense. And I think also when there's voting involved, it's fair to the other participants to disqualify icons that obviously don't fit the theme - it's the general principle of encouraging and affirming people who do read the rules and work within the parameters of the challenge.

[luminousdaze]

True. I haven't ever had a participant totally ignore the themes/prompts all together, as far as I can remember anyways. 🤷🏽‍♀️

[tinny]

Good! *knock on wood*

I've had several occasions at your_favourites where people entered too many icons, or icons of too many different things where only two are allowed each round, and some where people simply entered something that contradicted the rules that I posted - like icon a movie when the theme was tv show, or something like that. I'm sure none of them did it maliciously, they just didn't read the rules.

[tinny]

And now I have one at iconcolors this week. This one honestly stumps me. *sigh*